This 2CD set is a re-release of two separate recordings, 'Private Collection, No. 1' and Private Collection, No.2', that were originally released in very small quantities on the specialty audiophile, label Naim Audio in 1995.
CD1 was recorded on Charlie Haden's 50th birthday party at "My Place" in Santa Monica, CA on August 6th 1987. Not surprising, it has a slightly loose jam session feel to it, but the compositions and the high caliber of musicianship more than compensate for any looseness in the playing.
The tunes range from two Pat Metheny songs, "Hermitage" and "Farmer's Trust", to Miles Davis' "Nardis", to two Charlie Parker tunes "Passport" and "Segment"), to a tune each by Tony Scott "Misery" and J.S. Bach "Etudes", all which the group attacks in equal amounts of subtle fervor and restrained skill-all from many years of playing both together in Charlie's Quartet West and with many other jazz greats.
Along with Charlie Haden's bass are:
Ernie Watts on saxophones
Alan Broadbent on piano
Billy Higgins the drummer's drummer, who at the time of the recording played on and off with Charlie for three decades.
CD2 was recorded live on April 4th 1988, at Webster University, St Louis Mo. (near Charlie's boyhood home). It has identical personnel to CD1, except Billy Higgins, who is replaced with Paul Motian, another legendary jazz drummer.
In comparison to CD1, at least to my ears, these tracks have a bit more life in
them, thanks in large part to Ernie Watt's angular sounding sax, Paul Motian's
drumming is also a bit more forceful. As always, Charlie's bass playing (especially his solos) is truly intricate and engaging.
The compositions range from Pat Metheny's "Farmer's Trust" (again), to Charlie Parker's "Visa", to two tracks by Charlie "Bay City" and "Silence", to Ornette Coleman's "Lonely Woman", to the standard "Body and Soul".
Both CDs are Jazz from the days when melodies mattered, from true group interplay when a solo was something that was played strictly to advance the music, not the musician's ego. When musicians listened to each other and contributed something of true value. A time when the song was (is) the thing. If you like unpretentious, straight ahead, no nonsense Jazz, with great solos out in front of an equally fine rhythm section, this is one to listen to.
For the freeload, tell us about a memorable birthday you had.











































